Borders huntsman found not guilty of illegal fox hunting

The case against two members of the Buccleuch Hunt in the Borders charged with illegal fox hunting has concluded yesterday (Wednesday, 5th December) at Jedburgh Sheriff Court. One huntsman was found not guilty while the case against the second was withdrawn

Timothy Allen and Shaun Anderson both pled not guilty to deliberately hunting a wild mammal with dogs on land surrounding the village of Morebattle in the Scottish Borders on 20th Dec 2017. Huntsmen Allen and Anderson were charged with breaching Section 1(1) of The Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Act 2002 after video footage taken by the League Against Cruel Sports Scotland was passed to Police Scotland.

Sheriff Patterson concluded that the case against Allen was impossible to convict due to well documented difficulties with the legislation. He found Anderson not guilty of the charges against him on the grounds that there wasn’t enough evidence to prove he was deliberately hunting.

Robbie Marsland, Director of the League Against Cruel Sports, Scotland said:

“We are disappointed that despite clear evidence the case against Allen has been withdrawn and Anderson has been found not guilty. As has been the case on a number of occasions in the past, failings in the law which supposedly bans hunting in Scotland have made prosecution extremely difficult.

“Today’s outcome simply reinforces our view that the law is not fit for purpose and isn’t worth the paper it’s written on.”

In the 16 years since the Act was introduced, there has only been one successful prosecution for mounted fox hunting. The League Scotland is calling for the law to be strengthened and loopholes to be closed in order to prevent hunts evading prosecution.

A Scottish Government consultation on the workings of the fox hunting law, following a review by Lord Bonomy, closed in January this year. The analysis of the consultation illustrated huge support in favour of strengthening the law to really ban hunting in Scotland, with 98% indicating support or agreement with Lord Bonomy.

Despite this the Government has failed to make any decision on its intentions for the law and as a result, Green MSP Alison Johnstone has pledged to bring forward a Members Bill before the end of the year to introduce better protections for Scotland’s wildlife, including a complete ban on hunting with dogs.

Robbie Marsland added:

“We hope today will act as a wake up call to the Scottish Government that it must act now to improve the law. It is almost impossible for courts to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt due to the complexities of the current law which is clearly not working.

“We are disappointed that the Scottish Government has procrastinated for such a long time over fox hunting, engaging in a four year process which has got us precisely nowhere. The time has come for action to really ban hunting in Scotland.”


Notes to editor

  1. Footage can be downloaded here.
  2. Media enquiries to Louise Robertson on 07930 539832 /

Sign up for our newsletter

We'd love to keep in touch. With your permission we'll let you know the very latest news on our fast-moving campaigns, as well as appeals and other actions (such as petitions) so you can continue to help protect animals.

If you would like to know more about your data protection rights, please read our privacy policy.

© 2023 The League Against Cruel Sports. Registered charity in England and Wales (1095234) and Scotland (SC045533).
Registered in England and Wales as a company limited by guarantee, no. 04037610.
Registered office: New Sparling House, Holloway Hill, Godalming, GU7 1QZ, United Kingdom.